Sort By

Texas Jury Awards Woman $1.2M in J&J Transvaginal Mesh Case

courthouse pillars

A Texas jury recently ordered that Johnson & Johnson must pay $1.2 million to a former nurse who was injured by one of the manufacturer’s mesh slings used to treat incontinence.

Plaintiff Linda Batiste filed a lawsuit against the pharmaceutical giant when the TVT-O mesh sling implanted in her body to treat stress urinary incontinence (SUI) eroded, causing severe pelvic pain and damage.

Transvaginal mesh implants are typically made of porous, synthetic polyethylene plastic. Manufacturers of hernia mesh found a new market for the product for use in repairing pelvic floor disorders, but the products were not sufficiently tested in humans before implanting them in women. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) ordered mesh manufacturers to conduct additional safety studies in January 2012 because of growing concern over these products.

Jurors in the state court last week in Dallas ruled in favor of 64-year-old Batiste and concluded the device manufactured by the company’s Ethicon unit was defective, Bloomberg reported.

Attorneys in the federal cases believe this is the first of many more verdicts against J&J. “This verdict represents the first time an impartial jury had the opportunity to decide whether Ethicon’s sling products are defective, and they found exactly that,” Bryan Aylstock, a plaintiffs’ lawyer helping to oversee federal cases, told Bloomberg.

This is the first verdict against J&J for its vaginal mesh sling products, and the company plans to appeal.

“The jury’s verdict on design defect is disappointing, and we believe we have strong grounds for appeal,” Ethicon spokesman Matthew Johnson told Bloomberg.

J&J’s Ethicon division still faces more than 12,000 federal lawsuits. Experts expect more women will come forward in state and federal courts.

Tens of Thousands More Mesh Cases Pending

Including the lawsuits against J&J, there are now 43,000 federal lawsuits against seven manufacturers pending in federal court in West Virginia before Judge Joseph Goodwin.

Other transvaginal mesh manufacturers also face mounting legal battles as women continue filing lawsuits because of a long list of complications they suffered after the devices were implanted in their bodies. Plaintiffs suffered problems including erosion, inability to have intercourse, organ perforation and scarring.

The lawsuits state the products are defective and manufacturers failed to warn patients about the risks of complications.

Mesh manufacturers already paid millions to settle a number of claims. Coloplast was the most recent to pay out compensation to women implanted with mesh. The Danish company settled a number of cases for $16 million.

Advocates, Lawyers Claim J&J Deliberately Destroyed Mesh Documents

The nonprofit group Corporate Action Network is urging the U.S. Justice Department to investigate whether J&J deliberately destroyed documents that could be used as evidence in transvaginal mesh trials.

“Hundreds of thousands of women continue to suffer ongoing, severe harm [from J&J’s pelvic mesh implants]. I hope Johnson & Johnson is held accountable for their failure to warn,” network spokeswoman Levana Layendecker told The Associated Press.

In February, U.S. District Judge Cheryl Eifert ruled that J&J destroyed thousands of documents, but did not say that it was done intentionally.

Plaintiffs’ attorneys filed documents in court stating: “Ethicon’s document destruction has severely prejudiced the plaintiffs for the upcoming bellwether trials. Defendants should not benefit from the gaps in plaintiffs’ story that defendant created.”

J&J disagrees.

Johnson told Bloomberg, “We have never intentionally destroyed, withheld or failed to produce relevant documents.”

Last modified: March 30, 2017


Michelle Y. Llamas is a senior content writer. She is also the host of Drugwatch Podcast where she interviews medical experts as well as patients affected by drugs and medical devices. She has written medical and legal content for several years — including an article in The Journal of Palliative Medicine and an academic book review for Nova Science Publishers. With Drugwatch, she has developed relationships with legal and medical professionals as well as with several patients and support groups. Prior to writing for Drugwatch, she spent several years as a legal assistant for a personal injury law firm in Orlando. She obtained her English – Technical Communication degree from the University of Central Florida. She is a committee member with the American Medical Writers Association.

Hide Sources

  1. Feeley, J. (2013, December) J&J lost or destroyed vaginal-mesh files, lawyers contend. Bloomberg. Retrieved from
  2. Johnson, L. A. (2014, March 26). Women: J&J trashed records in product injury suits. San Angelo Standard-Times. Retrieved from
  3. Feeley, J. (2014, April 4). J&J must pay damages in mesh incontinence implant verdict loss. Bloomberg. Retrieved from
Free Transvaginal Mesh Case Review

Experiencing complications and side effects from your Transvaginal Mesh?
Get Help Now