(888) 645-1617

News

Sort By

GAO to Investigate Morcellators, FDA Clearance Process

Reflection of older man speaking at a hearing

In response to a request by 12 members of Congress, the U.S. Government Accountability Office agreed to open an investigation into the reason it took the U.S. Food and Drug Administration 20 years to warn of the risks power morcellators pose to patients.

Experts once believed power morcellators possessed a one in 1,000 risk of spreading uterine cancer during fibroid removal or hysterectomy surgery. The most recent statistic indicates the risk is one in 350.

According to the letter from the representatives, “Hundreds, if not thousands of women in America are dead because of a medical device known as the laparoscopic power morcellator.”

U.S. Reps. Mike Fitzpatrick and Louise Slaughter led the effort to request a GAO investigation.

“This device can take Stage 1 treatable cancer immediately to a Stage 4 terminal cancer,” the members of Congress wrote to the GAO in August. “For too many women, this routine procedure ended with a death sentence.”

The GAO managing director for congressional relations, Katherine Siggerud, told Fitzpatrick that the agency would begin an investigation “as work that is within the scope” of its authority, according to The Wall Street Journal. The investigation is expected to begin in five months.

The announcement comes two months after LiNA Medical settled the first power morcellator lawsuit before it could go to trial. About 20 other cases are scheduled to go to trial in 2015.

Experts expect hundreds of morcellator lawsuits to seek justice for women harmed, because manufacturers failed to warn of the risks of laparoscopic surgery.

Investigation Focuses on FDA 510(k) Clearance Process

The FDA cleared the first power morcellator in 1995 as a part of its 510(k) clearance process. The process is different from the FDA giving full approval, which would require clinical trials to prove a device is safe and effective.

Instead, manufacturers only have to prove that the device is similar enough to something already on the market before receiving FDA clearance to market it. The companies are supposed to monitor the device for any adverse events while it is on the market.

In their letter to the GAO, the members of Congress asked the agency to determine four things:

  • Did the FDA’s reliance on the 510(k) approval policies and procedures sufficiently identify risks of adverse events before the laparoscopic power morcellator was allowed to enter the market?
  • Were the medical device reporting regulations appropriately followed to protect patient safety in laparoscopic power morecellators by manufacturers, importers, user facilities and the FDA?
  • What activities or training did manufacturers provide to clinicians and what professional society standards, if any, apply to training on the use of these devices?
  • What steps is the FDA taking after issuing a black box warning to further determine whether the laparoscopic power morcellator is safe to remain on the market?

In November of 2014, the FDA issued a black-box warning indicating the risk of spreading unsuspected cancer is one in 350 and the devices should not be used in most women.

However, members of Congress pointed out multiple studies conducted in the ‘90s that showed the risk as high:

  • A 1990 study indicated one out of every 200 women possesses hidden uterine sarcoma (cancer).
  • A 1994 study indicated the risk was one out of every 444.
  • Various studies from 1999 to 2008 found the risk to be between one in 462 and one in 253.

The members of Congress wrote, “the FDA, the medical device industry, and many gynecologists pointed to the risk of a hidden cancer as being low, only one-in-10,000. How did they get it wrong for so long?”

The Federal Bureau of Investigation wants to know the answer too.

GAO Investigation Follows Reports of FBI Investigation

In May of 2015, the FBI began investigating information regarding power morcellators and manufacturer Johnson & Johnson’s knowledge of the potential dangers of the device, according to WSJ and New York Times reports.

J&J removed its morcellator from the market in July of 2014. The FBI’s Newark New Jersey office declined the WSJ and NYT’s requests for comment.

The newspapers reported FBI agents had interviewed three high-profile sources. One was retired pathologist, Dr. Robert Lamparter who reportedly warned J&J about the risks in 2006.  Another was a highly-publicized doctor who developed cancer after a surgery involving power morcellators, Dr. Amy Reed. The third was a California physician’s assistant who had gathered almost 400 names of people harmed by the device.

The FBI could pursue criminal charges if it finds any evidence of wrongdoing. That would be in addition to the civil charges companies already face.

Last modified: July 6, 2017


Chris Elkins is a writer and researcher for Drugwatch.com. He’s worked for various newspapers and has writing experience in sports, health communication and public relations fields. He graduated from the University of West Florida with a master’s degree in Strategic Communication and Leadership, a graduate-level certificate in Health Communication Leadership and a bachelor’s degree in Journalism.

Hide Sources

  1. Fitzpatrick, M., et al. (2015, August 7). Letter to GAO calling for investigation of power morcellators. Retrieved from: http://www.cancerletter.com/downloads/20150911_1/download
  2. Levitz, J. (2015, May 27). FBI is investigating hysterectomy device found to spread uterine cancer. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from: http://www.wsj.com/articles/fbi-is-investigating-surgical-device-1432746641
  3. Levitz, K. (2015, August 7). Members of Congress call on GAO to investigate surgical tool. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from: http://www.wsj.com/articles/members-of-congress-call-on-gao-to-investigate-surgical-tool-1438978884
  4. Kamp, J. (2015, September 4). Government watchdog to investigate hysterectomy device found to spread uterine cancer. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from: http://www.wsj.com/articles/government-watchdog-to-investigate-hysterectomy-device-found-to-spread-uterine-cancer-1441385550