News

Sort By

Doctor Who Campaigned Against Morcellators Dies of Cancer

candles and red flowers

Dr. Amy Reed, who used her own cancer to fight for other women, has died less than four years after a device used in her fibroid-removal surgery spread the aggressive, previously undetected cancer throughout her body.

The 44-year-old mother of six had teamed up with her husband, Hooman Noorchashm, another physician, to campaign for a ban on the use of power morcellators, devices used in laparoscopic surgery to slice up tissue so it can be removed through small incisions.

Days before Reed died, her husband wrote a mass email in which he called her, “a mother, a doctor and a warrior the likes of whom the world does not see often.”

Just 13 months after her youngest child was born in 2013, Reed had her fibroid surgery at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, which is affiliated with Harvard Medical School. Both Reed and Noorchashm held teaching positions at the medical school at the time.

A biopsy after the surgery revealed the undiagnosed, aggressive cancer leiomyosarcoma. Because of the use of the morcellator, the cancer was scattered throughout Reed’s abdominal cavity like shrapnel. This process transforms Stage 1 cancers into Stage 4.

If the cancer had been taken out whole, Reed’s five-year survival odds would have been 50 percent. With the cancer morcellated, her chances were between zero and 20 percent. “Basically,” Noorchashm later told Philly Magazine, “they created a man-made stage-4 cancer.”

Enraged at what happened to his wife and determined to stop it from happening to anyone else, Noorchashm began an unrelenting effort to petition regulators, lawmakers, journalists and the medical establishment and shine a light on the dangers.

Achieving Reform

Through the couple’s efforts, other women stepped forward, and the U.S. Food & Drug Administration studied the issue, changing estimates of how many women with fibroids had undiagnosed uterine sarcomas from 1 in 10,000 to 1 in 500. The agency issued a recommendation in 2014 that morcellators should not be used in the vast majority of uterine fibroid surgeries. According to the New York Times, insurers started refusing to cover surgical procedures that used morcellators. Johnson & Johnson subsequently pulled its device off the market. But other companies continue to market morcellators.

Reed used the attention to found “Slay Sarcoma,” a nonprofit to raise awareness and funding for research into leiomyosarcoma.

Dr Amy Reed and her family

Dr. Amy Reed, a 44-year-old mother of six, had teamed up with her husband, Hooman Noorchashm, another physician, to campaign for a ban on the use of power morcellators. She died Wednesday (May 24)

The couple caught the attention of U.S. Rep. Mike Fitzpatrick, (R-Pa), who led a bipartisan coalition of 12 members of Congress to request the Government Accountability Office investigation, which found in February that the FDA was aware of the danger when it approved the first power morcellator in 1991. Still, the devices benefitted from a limited approval process in which they received a green light because they were similar to other instruments used in different parts of the body. The GAO report also concluded that a weak reporting system deterred doctors and hospitals from telling the FDA about incidents in which morcellators spread cancer.

In fact, although hundreds of women had the same experience — one lay dying in the same hospital when Reed had her fibroid surgery — Reed’s was the first reported to the FDA as an adverse event.

As a result, Fitzpatrick also introduced legislation to encourage physicians to identify and report such dangers to the FDA.

Fitzpatrick released a statement regarding Reed’s death, calling her “a recognized physician, exemplary mother and wife, and dedicated patient advocate.”

“Dr. Reed didn’t ask for the situation she found herself in following a procedure in 2013, but it was immediately evident to anyone that met her — and her family — that she was going to be a fighter, not only for herself, but others,” Fitzpatrick said. “Through her and her loving husband, Hooman’s campaign to bring awareness to the dangers of power morcellators there is no doubt women’s lives have been saved and device manufacturers and regulators have been forced to review their safety protocols and standards. This is Amy’s gift — and we are eternally grateful.“

The couple moved to Pennsylvania in 2014 and went to work at the University of Pennsylvania.

Tension Between Ethics and Profits

Noorchashm told an interviewer he saw the battle as a struggle between the ethical dictate that doctors do no harm and the pressures of American corporate medicine.

“What’s happened here is, an entire establishment is willing to say, ‘We’re going to take the collateral damage,’” he told Philly magazine.

He said he saw his battle as a patriotic imperative. “This goes to the heart of what government is for—to protect individual rights, property, and health,” he told the magazine. “The Declaration of Independence is a human-rights document. You can’t sacrifice a minority for the sake of the majority.”

Reed suffered cardiac arrest in April, but fought back, although Noorchashm said she was not supposed to survive that episode. On April 29, he posted a picture on Facebook of his wife smiling in her hospital bed.

“Here, smiles the shape of Hope,” he wrote. “Outside the boxes and walls that constrain most…..WEAK! Here, Hope lives….and will live. Who knows what tomorrow will bring…health, illness, wealth, destitute, tragedy, gladness? We….not one of us, knows. But we have today, we have now – all we really have is today and the now.”

Last modified: December 1, 2017

Author

Elaine Silvestrini is a career journalist with a strong desire to learn, explain, and help people. At Drugwatch, Elaine has reported about trials over whether talcum powder caused ovarian cancer and allegations that Androgel causes heart problems in patients who use it. She has chronicled the billions of dollars generated for big pharmaceutical companies by certain drugs and efforts to warn consumers about the dangers of specific medical problems. Elaine has received six health literacy certificates for completing courses offered by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. She brings more than 20 years of experience covering state and federal court systems, learning the intricacies of criminal and civil law, developing investigative pieces about how the law affects people’s lives and digging through and digesting reams of court records on a daily basis.

Hide Sources

  1. Noorchashm, H. (2017, April 29). Retrieved https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100007253070732&hc_ref=SEARCH
  2. Grady, D. (2017, May 24). Amy Reed, Doctor Who Fought a Risky Medical Procedure, Dies at 44. Retrieved https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/24/us/amy-reed-died-cancer-patient-who-fought-morcellation-procedure.html?_r=0
  3. Grady, D. (2017, February 8). Weak Reporting System Let Risky Surgical Device Stay in Use. Retrieved https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/08/health/morcellator-gao-report-fda.html
  4. McCullough, M. (2017, May 24). Philly patient-safety advocate, physician Amy Reed, dies at 44. Retrieved http://www.philly.com/philly/health/Philly-patient-safety-advocate-physician-Amy-Reed-dies-leiomyosarcoma-morcellator-Penn-FDA.html
  5. Hingston, S. (2016, March). What Are the Chances? A Tale of Love vs. Big Medicine. Retrieved http://www.phillymag.com/articles/amy-reed-morcellation/
  6. Hingston, S. (2017, February 10). Bucks Couple Vindicated by Report on Dangerous Medical Device. Retrieved http://www.phillymag.com/news/2017/02/10/amy-reed-morcellator-fda/
  7. McCullough, M. (2016, October 26). Patient-safety advocate Amy Reed recovering from ‘high-risk’ surgery. Retrieved http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/diagnosis-cancer/Patient-safety-advocate-Amy-Reed-recovering-from-high-risk-surgery.html?mobi=true
  8. Levitz, J. (2017, May 24). Doctor Who Battled Against Hysterectomy Procedure Dies. Retrieved https://www.wsj.com/articles/doctor-who-battled-against-hysterectomy-procedure-dies-1495676064?mod=e2fb
  9. Voelker, R. (2017, March 21). Morcellator Risk Was Known. Retrieved http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/2612598
  10. Fitzpatrick, B. (2017, May 24). Statement on the Passing of Dr. Amy Reed