Why are people filing hernia mesh lawsuits?
Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuit
Some patients who received Bard or Davol hernia mesh implants have filed thousands of lawsuits. They allege that defective mesh caused serious complications, repeat surgeries and lasting injuries. While a major settlement resolved many claims, new lawsuits are still being accepted.
Our content is developed and backed by respected legal, medical and scientific experts. More than 30 contributors, including product liability attorneys and board-certified physicians, have reviewed our website to ensure it’s medically sound and legally accurate.
legal help when you need it most.
Drugwatch has provided people injured by harmful drugs and devices with reliable answers and experienced legal help since 2009. Brought to you by The Wilson Firm LLP, we've pursued justice for more than 20,000 families and secured $324 million in settlements and verdicts against negligent manufacturers.
More than 30 contributors, including mass tort attorneys and board-certified doctors, have reviewed our website and added their unique perspectives to ensure you get the most updated and highest quality information.
Drugwatch.com is AACI-certified as a trusted medical content website and is produced by lawyers, a patient advocate and award-winning journalists whose affiliations include the American Bar Association and the American Medical Writers Association.
About Drugwatch.com
- 17 Years of Advocacy
- $324 Million Recovered for Clients
- 20,000 Families Helped
- A+ BBB Rating
- 4.9 Stars from Google Reviews
Testimonials
I found Drugwatch to be very helpful with finding the right lawyers. We had the opportunity to share our story as well, so that more people can be aware of NEC. We are forever grateful for them.
- Last update: August 3, 2026
- Est. Read Time: 4 min read
Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuit Overview
Bard hernia mesh lawsuits focus on products made by C.R. Bard and Davol, which are now part of Becton, Dickinson and Company (BD). People have filed these lawsuits because Bard and Davol’s polypropylene mesh products have been linked to serious problems after hernia surgery.
Although Bard offered a settlement in 2024, there are still 23,321 active lawsuits in an Ohio federal court. Lawyers continue to accept new claims, so anyone with serious hernia mesh injuries can still request a free case review.
The lawsuits are part of a federal multidistrict litigation (MDL), a process that consolidates similar lawsuits into a single case to streamline the litigation.
Why Are People Filing Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuits?
People are filing Bard hernia mesh lawsuits because the company’s mesh products failed after surgery and caused serious health problems.
These cases question whether mesh defects directly caused patient complications. They cite issues such as adhesions, organ damage, inflammation, allergic reactions, foreign-body rejection, mesh movement and infections.
See If You Qualify For a Hernia Mesh Lawsuit
Key Legal Allegations in Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuits
The main lawsuit claims are that the Bard mesh products were poorly designed, inadequately tested and that the manufacturer failed to explain the risks.
Cases in the MDL do not list every individual mesh product. Instead, they cover Bard and Davol products overall, because their claims focus on design and material problems that could affect many devices.
Lawsuits say the mesh can break down or cause inflammation after surgery, leading to pain and other problems.
Bard Hernia Mesh Injuries
The Bard lawsuits focus on problems that can appear after hernia surgery and worsen over time. These complications may lead to repeated doctor visits or emergency treatment. They can also make it harder to work, exercise or do normal activities.
- Adhesions
- Allergic reactions
- Foreign body rejection
- Infections
- Inflammation
- Mesh movement
- Organ damage
These issues can be painful and may require more medical care, such as scans, medication or another surgery. For many patients, the hardest part is not the injury but the long recovery process and the possibility that the mesh will need to be removed.
Bard Hernia Mesh MDL Status and Timeline
The Bard hernia mesh lawsuits have moved from trials to settlement. The MDL is still a key part of the case history. As of August 2026, there were 23,321 active lawsuits remaining in the Bard MDL.
Key Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuit Dates
-
December 16, 2024:
Judge Sargus issued Case Management Order 56 to set up a qualified settlement fund for Bard claims, which should include about 38,000 cases. Settlement payments will be made over time.
-
October 2, 2024:
BD announced plans to resolve most Bard hernia mesh claims. The company agreed to settle about 38,000 lawsuits, marking a major turning point in the case.
-
July 6, 2024:
Judge Sargus paused pretrial activity in Bard cases filed before this date. The order indicated that settlement talks were happening. It also gave plaintiffs more leverage by allowing them to opt out of the master settlement agreement.
-
February 29, 2024:
The court ordered both sides to attend mediation after the final bellwether trial was indefinitely postponed. Mediation was scheduled for March 25 and 26, 2024.
-
February 1, 2024:
Judge Sargus canceled the fourth bellwether trial and denied the plaintiffs’ request to send cases back to lower courts. He explained that another long trial would not be helpful.
-
January 31, 2024:
Bard filed a motion requesting that the judge dismiss the $500,000 Aaron Stinson verdict. The judge denied the request, so the plaintiff’s award remained unchanged.
-
January 10, 2024:
After three bellwether trials, both sides were expected to decide on next steps. Another status conference was set for February 6.
-
December 21, 2023:
Plaintiffs’ leaders filed a motion to send a portion of cases back to their original courts, saying some people had waited almost six years for relief.
-
November 8, 2023:
A federal jury in Ohio awarded Aaron Stinson $500,000 in the most recent Bard bellwether trial.
-
April 15, 2022:
A jury awarded Antonio Milanesi $255,000 in the second Bard bellwether trial.
-
September 8, 2021:
The first hernia mesh bellwether trial ended with a verdict in favor of C.R. Bard.
-
August 2, 2018:
The JPML created MDL 2846. This action moved the Bard and Davol polypropylene hernia mesh cases to the Southern District of Ohio for coordinated pretrial proceedings.
Bard Hernia Mesh Settlements and Compensation
In October 2024, BD agreed to settle about 38,000 Bard hernia mesh lawsuits. The company set aside $1.9 billion to cover its product liability costs, with payments to be made over several years.
The exact payout amounts are not public, so there is no average number for each case. For mass tort cases like this, the final payment usually depends on the type of injury, whether revision surgery was needed, the quality of the medical records and whether there is strong evidence that the device failed.
The company also faced multiple jury verdicts in state and MDL bellwether trials. Bellwether trials are test cases that determine the strength of each side’s argument. These could shape hernia mesh settlements down the line.
- November 2023: $500,000 bellwether verdict
- August 2022: $4.8 million Rhode Island state court verdict
- April 2022: $255,000 bellwether verdict
What Influences Settlement Value
Settlement value usually depends on the severity of the injury and the amount of treatment the patient needed. Cases that involve revision surgery, bowel injury, infection or long-term pain often get more attention than those with only short-term symptoms.
It’s important to have good medical records to track your problems and treatment history. The case location also matters because jury pools and past verdicts may affect a case’s value. In many instances, people with the clearest records and the most severe injuries receive the highest compensation.
Who Qualifies for a Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuit?
You might be eligible for a lawsuit if you had a Bard or Davol hernia mesh implant and later developed serious complications linked to the device.
- You were implanted with Bard hernia mesh.
- You experienced a related injury, including adhesions, foreign body rejection, infections, mesh migration or organ damage.
- The implant happened after 2013, and you had a surgical intervention or revision or are scheduled for one.
- Your revision surgery happened in 2017 or later.
- If there was no surgical correction, you must have experienced substantial medical treatment, such as infection care or nerve blocks/neurectomy.
Usually, a lawyer will need to review your implant history and see proof that the mesh caused actual harm. Claims are usually stronger if you needed revision surgery, had serious infection treatment or required other major care for mesh-related injuries.
Timing is also important in Bard cases, as each state has its own statute of limitations. This is a time limit that begins when you first discover your injury. Older cases might not qualify even if the injury is severe, so it’s important to speak to a lawyer to learn the deadlines for your case.
How To File a Bard Hernia Mesh Lawsuit
Filing a Bard hernia mesh lawsuit usually begins with a consultation. A free case review with Drugwatch can help you determine if you qualify. An experienced hernia mesh lawyer will check if your surgery, implant and injuries meet the requirements for a lawsuit. You don’t have to pay anything unless you win your case.
The whole process involves a few simple steps.
- Start with a case evaluation to see whether you may have a Bard mesh claim.
- Collect evidence, including operation reports, implant records, imaging, follow-up visits and revision surgery records.
- Speak with a product liability lawyer who can review your injury, device and filing deadline.
- If the case moves forward, it may be filed into MDL 2846 for coordinated proceedings.
After submitting the review through Drugwatch, an attorney will reach out if your case meets the criteria. This service is free, and you are not required to proceed with a lawsuit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Calling this number connects you with a Drugwatch.com representative. We will direct you to one of our trusted legal partners for a free case review.
Drugwatch.com's trusted legal partners support the organization's mission to keep people safe from dangerous drugs and medical devices. For more information, visit our partners page.