Sort By

Judge Denies J&J’s Bid to Toss $15M Mesh Verdict

judge with gavel

A New Jersey judge this week upheld a $15M transvaginal mesh verdict against Johnson & Johnson’s Ethicon unit.

On March 5, 2018, Judge Rachelle Lea Harz denied Ethicon’s motion to reverse the verdict and hold a new trial. The mesh maker did not warn about the risks of the Prolift and TVT-O devices, Harz ruled.

Elizabeth Hyrmoc is the plaintiff in the case. The 71-year-old woman’s lawsuit claimed Ethicon’s mesh devices were defective and the company failed to warn about risks. She said she suffered from an inability to have sex, vaginal erosion and chronic pain after receiving the device.

Hyrmoc’s case originally went to trial in November 2017.

After the two and a half week trial, the jury awarded Hyrmoc and her husband $15 million in damages.

Out of the $15 million verdict, the jury awarded the couple $10 million for punitive damages. Juries award punitive damages to punish a defendant for harmful behavior.

Minutes after the jury announced the verdict, Ethicon said it would appeal, reported.

Injured by complications related to transvaginal mesh? We can help.

“Ethicon intends to appeal this verdict, as we believe that the evidence showed that the company appropriately informed surgeons of pertinent complications and that the products were properly designed and studied,” a company spokeswoman told the news outlet.

The mesh maker had appealed an earlier $11 million verdict awarded to Linda Gross in New Jersey.

Gross received three surgeries to correct vaginal mesh complications. Like Hyrmoc, Gross also received Ethicon’s Prolift mesh.

In December 2016, the Supreme Court of New Jersey denied Ethicon’s appeal, upholding Gross’ verdict.

Hyrmoc is one of several thousand women who sued Ethicon over faulty mesh implants in state and federal courts across the country.

Ethicon still faces over 13,600 federal lawsuits over its mesh products. At one time, the number was about 40,000.

Other mesh manufacturers have already settled thousands of cases. For example, American Medical Systems settled about 40,000 cases for an estimated $2.6 billion in 2017.

So far, J&J and Ethicon have yet to offer any mesh settlements.

Last modified: March 7, 2018


Michelle Y. Llamas is a senior content writer. She is also the host of Drugwatch Podcast where she interviews medical experts as well as patients affected by drugs and medical devices. She has written medical and legal content for several years — including an article in The Journal of Palliative Medicine and an academic book review for Nova Science Publishers. With Drugwatch, she has developed relationships with legal and medical professionals as well as with several patients and support groups. Prior to writing for Drugwatch, she spent several years as a legal assistant for a personal injury law firm in Orlando. She obtained her English – Technical Communication degree from the University of Central Florida. She is a committee member with the American Medical Writers Association.

Hide Sources

  1. Martyn, A. (2016, December 16). New Jersey court upholds $11 million verdict in state's first pelvic mesh case. Retrieved from
  2. Cowan, R. (2017, December 14). Jury awards $15 million in damages in pelvic mesh case. Retrieved from
Free Transvaginal Mesh Case Review

Experiencing complications and side effects from your Transvaginal Mesh?
Get Help Now