Transvaginal Mesh Victim ‘Satisfied’ by Revised Verdict of $20M

Fact-Checked

Editors carefully fact-check all Drugwatch content for accuracy and quality.

Drugwatch has a stringent fact-checking process. It starts with our strict sourcing guidelines.

We only gather information from credible sources. This includes peer-reviewed medical journals, reputable media outlets, government reports, court records and interviews with qualified experts.

Gavel and Themis statue

A woman awarded $35 million after suffering severe injuries from Johnson & Johnson’s Prolift transvaginal mesh is ‘satisfied’ by a federal judge’s revised verdict of $20 million, her attorney told DrugWatch.

Barbara Kaiser was awarded $10 million in compensatory damages and $25 million in punitive damages by an Indiana federal jury following a more than one-week-long trial on March 8, 2018.

U.S. District Judge Philip P. Simon later cut the $25 million punitive damages awarded by an Indiana federal jury to $10 million.

Judge Adjusts Amount Based on Prolift sales in Indiana

Simon of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana ruled that the jury erred in its setting of the amount of punitive damages.

Injured by complications related to Transvaginal Mesh? Get a Free Case Review

Punitive damages are used to punish the wrongdoer or deter them from future wrongdoing. But Simon said the jury improperly decided the amount based on a percentage of J&J’s total net worth ($70 billion) rather than the company’s profits on the Prolift device specific to its Indiana sales of $150,000.

In other words, the $25 million awarded in punitive damages to Kaiser was 166 times the relevant profits earned by J&J and Ethicon on its Prolift mesh sold in a single state.

The judge ruled instead that the award be set at $10 million, giving Kaiser a sum of $20 million in total damages.

Attorney Expresses Satisfaction with $20M Award

An attorney for Kaiser, Thomas O. Plouff, said Simon acted within his discretion in reducing the punitive damages.

“We believe the $25 million in punitive damages awarded by the jury would be more of a deterrent to a $70 billion company knowingly selling a dangerous and harmful medical device,” Plouff said. But he continued, “Given that Simon decided the jury properly awarded $10 million in compensatory damages… we decided it best to accept the remittitur.”

Remittitur is a legal term that simply means a ruling by a judge that lowers an excessive verdict – or amount of damages granted by a jury in a civil case.

“We are satisfied with the final judgment,” Plouff concluded.

Thousands of Mesh Lawsuits Pending in U.S.

Kaiser was one of thousands of injured women who sued J&J and its subsidiary Ethicon over its transvaginal mesh implant sold under the brand name Prolift. She suffered from severe pain in the vaginal area and permanent injury that required corrective surgery after her doctor implanted her with the mesh device.

The jury returned the $35 million verdict after it decided that J&J and Ethicon manufactured a defective product and then failed to adequately warn patients and doctors about its risks.

Thousands of mesh lawsuits filed by injured women across the U.S. are still pending against J&J and Ethicon.

  •  
  •  
  •  

2 Cited Research Articles

  1. Sammon, J. (2018, August 15). Federal judge cuts vaginal mesh punitive award; Woman must take lesser amount or go through new trial. Legal NewsLine. Retrieved from https://legalnewsline.com/stories/511529753-federal-judge-cuts-vaginal-mesh-punitive-award-woman-must-take-lesser-amount-or-go-through-new-trial
  2. Plouff, T. (2018, September 14). Email interview.
View All Sources
Call to speak with a legal expert
Who Am I Calling?

Calling this number connects you with Wilson and Peterson, LLP or one of its trusted legal partners. A law firm representative will review your case for free.

Wilson and Peterson, LLP funds Drugwatch because it supports the organization’s mission to keep people safe from dangerous drugs and medical devices.

(844) 480-1538

To contact Drugwatch Managing Editor Kevin Connolly, call (855) 839-9780.