Hernia Mesh Failure

Hernia mesh failure occurs when surgical mesh has to be removed because it’s causing complications. Some of the most common symptoms of hernia mesh failure include abdominal pain, infection and hernia recurrence.

Last Modified: May 26, 2021
Fact Checked
Fact-Checked

Editors carefully fact-check all Drugwatch content for accuracy and quality.

Drugwatch has a stringent fact-checking process. It starts with our strict sourcing guidelines.

We only gather information from credible sources. This includes peer-reviewed medical journals, reputable media outlets, government reports, court records and interviews with qualified experts.

Most non-absorbable hernia mesh implants are supposed to be permanent and stay in the body indefinitely, according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The net-like mesh provides permanent reinforcement to repair hernias, keeping organs and tissues in place.

Some types of hernia mesh are more prone to fail. This may happen because of a product defect or poor design.

When mesh fails and causes serious problems, doctors have to perform revision surgery to treat complications such as hernia recurrence, hernia mesh infection, scarring and bowel obstruction.

Symptoms of Hernia Mesh Failure

Symptoms of hernia mesh failure may occur any time from weeks to years after surgery. The most common symptom of mesh failure is chronic pain.

If left untreated, failed mesh can lead to potentially life-threatening complications.

Signs of mesh failure include:
  • Pain - Pain from hernia mesh failure may be caused by excessive scar tissue, inflammation, nerve damage or mesh shrinkage. A failed inguinal hernia repair may cause groin pain and testicular pain.
  • Infection - Hernia mesh infections happen when bacteria builds up on the implant causing flu-like symptoms, fatigue, fever, swelling and tenderness around the surgery site.
  • Bowel Obstruction - Scar tissue from the implant may block the bowel and lead to constipation, vomiting, bloating and nausea. A complete obstruction is a medical emergency.
  • Hernia Recurrence - When hernia mesh fails, it can degrade, break or move from the original surgical site. This causes the hernia to come back.
  • Bulging - Bulging at the hernia site may be a signal of hernia recurrence, dislodged mesh or infection.
  • Sexual Problems - When mesh impinges on nerves, the spermatic cord or causes inflammation, this can lead to impotence in men.
Dr. Robert Bendavid details the characteristics of hernia mesh failure.

What Causes Hernia Mesh Failure?

There is no one cause of hernia mesh failure, and it’s often the result of a combination of factors. These include product design, a patient’s preexisting health conditions and surgical technique.

Product Design

If mesh material is too heavy and has very small pores, it is more likely to cause infection that leads to failure. Mesh that is too small to cover the hernia and that is prone to shrinkage can lead to failure.

Some types of mesh may not be effective at encouraging tissue ingrowth. Tissue ingrowth is crucial to keeping the material in place and forming a strong repair.

For example, one patient who had hernia repaired with Atrium’s fish-oil coated C-QUR mesh reported to the FDA that she never recovered from her initial surgery. She suffered severe, constant burning pain. The surgeon discovered the mesh was “floating freely/not attached,” according to the adverse event report in FDA’s MAUDE database.

Faulty mesh complications that lead to mesh failure include:
  • Infection – mesh infection is a complication that almost always requires surgical removal of mesh
  • Breakage – mesh can break, causing hernia recurrence, pain and other problems
  • Shrinkage – when mesh shrinks it pulls tissues together, causing chronic pain
  • Migration – mesh moves from the original surgery site, protruding from tissues and potentially causing organ perforation, hernia recurrence and pain
  • Rejection – mesh may cause an immune response and inflammation; symptoms include pain, redness and flu-like symptoms

Health Conditions, Medications and Cancer Treatments

Some health conditions, medications and cancer treatments may increase the risk for hernia mesh failure. People may reduce their risk by managing their weight, stopping smoking and getting proper nutrition.

Risk factors for mesh failure include:
  • Anemia
  • Certain autoimmune diseases (lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, etc.)
  • Chemotherapy
  • Chronic lung disease
  • Impaired blood clotting (coagulopathy)
  • Jaundice
  • Male gender
  • Malnutrition
  • Obesity
  • Radiotherapy
  • Smoking
  • Steroids
  • Type 2 diabetes

Surgical Technique

Poor surgical technique and lack of surgical experience may increase the likelihood that mesh will fail early.

In general, hernias are more likely to reoccur after open surgical techniques than laparoscopic techniques. But laparoscopic surgery is more challenging and has a greater learning curve.

“To achieve the best possible results, it requires an acceptance of a longer learning curve, structured well-mentored training and high level of standardization of the operative procedure,” according to a 2006 article in the Journal of Minimal Access Surgery by Jan F. Kukleta.

gavel icon
Did you experience serious complications after your hernia mesh failed?

What to Do if Your Mesh Failed

Some mesh failure symptoms such as infection and bowel obstruction can be life threatening. If you have any symptoms of mesh failure, make sure you talk to your doctor right away.

The doctor will examine you physically and may use x-rays, MRIs or other imaging techniques to check on the mesh. The main treatment for failure mesh is surgical removal. If there is a mesh infection, doctors will recommend intravenous antibiotics.

Make sure you talk to your doctor about revision surgery options. The doctor may recommend removing all or part of the failed mesh. Doctors might not know the extent of the problem until they begin surgery, and you may have more than one surgery.

If you plan on pursuing a lawsuit, make sure you preserve the mesh for evidence.

Does Hernia Mesh Have a High Failure Rate?

Most data on hernia mesh failure rates is not consistent because study designs aren’t consistent. The type of surgery, type of mesh, type of patient and the surgeon’s experience all factor into recurrence rates. This makes it difficult to have a fixed failure rate.

“With long-term follow-up, the benefits attributable to mesh are offset in part by mesh-related complications.”
Drs. Dunja Kokotovic, Thue Bisgaard and Frederik Helgstrand
Source: JAMA

One 2016 study by Dr. Dunja Kokotovic and colleagues published in JAMA looked at the five-year risk of reoperation for hernia recurrence and all other complications requiring more surgery in patients who had incisional hernia repair.

Out of 3,242 patients, they found the cumulative incidence of mesh-related complications was 5.6 percent for open hernia repair and 3.7 percent for patients who had laparoscopic hernia repair.

Another study by B.L. Murphy and colleagues published in Hernia in 2019 looked at the recurrence rates in 407,717 patients with inguinal hernia repairs. Authors found recurrence rates of 14.3 percent in 2011 and 13.9 percent in 2014.

Hernia Mesh Failure Lawsuits

Some mesh brands and types have higher failure rates than others. Patients who had hernia surgery with these mesh brands filed lawsuits against manufacturers after their mesh failed.

One brand, Ethicon’s Physiomesh Flexible Composite Mesh, was pulled from the market in May 2016 after two independent hernia studies showed the product had higher than average rates of reoperation and hernia recurrence.

Patients claim these meshes were poorly designed, defective and have higher than expected failure rates.

Manufacturers and Products in Lawsuits Include:
ManufacturerProduct
C.R. Bard, Davol (Bard Davol)PerFix, Kugel, 3DMax, Composix, Ventralex ST, Ventralex Patch, Supramesh
Ethicon/Johnson & Johnson Prolene, Proceed, Physiomesh Flexible Composite
Atrium MedicalC-QUR mesh and v-patches
Covidien/MedtronicComposite, ProGrip, Parietex
Please seek the advice of a medical professional before making health care decisions.